“知假买假、假一罚三、假一罚十”统一判：法释〔2024〕9号发布-律赢时代

“知假买假、假一罚三、假一罚十”统一判：法释〔2024〕9号发布

2024-08-23 经济纠纷 456次

《最高人民法院关于审理食品药品惩罚性赔偿纠纷案件适用法律若干问题的解释》已于2024年3月18日经最高人民法院审判委员会第1918次会议通过，现予公布，自2024年8月22日起施行。

最高人民法院

2024年8月21日

法释〔2024〕9号

最高人民法院

关于审理食品药品惩罚性赔偿纠纷案件

适用法律若干问题的解释

（2024年3月18日最高人民法院审判委员会第1918次会议通过，自2024年8月22日起施行）

为正确审理食品药品惩罚性赔偿纠纷案件，依法保护食品药品安全和消费者合法权益，根据《中华人民共和国民法典》、《中华人民共和国消费者权益保护法》、《中华人民共和国食品安全法》、《中华人民共和国药品管理法》等法律规定，结合审判实践，制定本解释。

第一条 购买者因个人或者家庭生活消费需要购买的食品不符合食品安全标准，购买后依照食品安全法第一百四十八条第二款规定请求生产者或者经营者支付惩罚性赔偿金的，人民法院依法予以支持。

没有证据证明购买者明知所购买食品不符合食品安全标准仍然购买的，人民法院应当根据购买者请求以其实际支付价款为基数计算价款十倍的惩罚性赔偿金。

第二条 购买者明知所购买食品不符合食品安全标准或者所购买药品是假药、劣药，购买后请求经营者返还价款的，人民法院应予支持。

经营者请求购买者返还食品、药品，如果食品标签、标志或者说明书不符合食品安全标准，食品生产者在采取补救措施且能保证食品安全的情况下可以继续销售的，人民法院应予支持；应当对食品、药品采取无害化处理、销毁等措施的，依照食品安全法、药品管理法的相关规定处理。

第三条 受托人明知购买者委托购买的是不符合食品安全标准的食品或者假药、劣药仍然代购，购买者依照食品安全法第一百四十八条第二款或者药品管理法第一百四十四条第三款规定请求受托人承担惩罚性赔偿责任的，人民法院应予支持，但受托人不以代购为业的除外。

以代购为业的受托人明知是不符合食品安全标准的食品或者假药、劣药仍然代购，向购买者承担惩罚性赔偿责任后向生产者追偿的，人民法院不予支持。受托人不知道是不符合食品安全标准的食品或者假药、劣药而代购，向购买者承担赔偿责任后向生产者追偿的，人民法院依法予以支持。

第四条 食品生产加工小作坊和食品摊贩等生产经营的食品不符合食品安全标准，购买者请求生产者或者经营者依照食品安全法第一百四十八条第二款规定承担惩罚性赔偿责任的，人民法院应予支持。

食品生产加工小作坊和食品摊贩等生产经营的食品不符合省、自治区、直辖市制定的具体管理办法等规定，但符合食品安全标准，购买者请求生产者或者经营者依照食品安全法第一百四十八条第二款规定承担惩罚性赔偿责任的，人民法院不予支持。

第五条 食品不符合食品中危害人体健康物质的限量规定，食品添加剂的品种、使用范围、用量要求，特定人群的主辅食品的营养成分要求，与卫生、营养等食品安全要求有关的标签、标志、说明书要求以及与食品安全有关的质量要求等方面的食品安全标准，购买者依照食品安全法第一百四十八条第二款规定请求生产者或者经营者承担惩罚性赔偿责任的，人民法院应予支持。

第六条 购买者以食品的标签、说明书不符合食品安全标准为由请求生产者或者经营者支付惩罚性赔偿金，生产者或者经营者以食品的标签、说明书瑕疵不影响食品安全且不会对消费者造成误导为由进行抗辩，存在下列情形之一的，人民法院对生产者或者经营者的抗辩不予支持：

（一）未标明食品安全标准要求必须标明的事项，但属于本解释第八条规定情形的除外；

（二）故意错标食品安全标准要求必须标明的事项；

（三）未正确标明食品安全标准要求必须标明的事项，足以导致消费者对食品安全产生误解。

第七条 购买者以食品的标签、说明书不符合食品安全标准为由请求生产者或者经营者支付惩罚性赔偿金，生产者或者经营者以食品的标签、说明书虽不符合食品安全标准但不影响食品安全为由进行抗辩的，人民法院对其抗辩不予支持，但食品的标签、说明书瑕疵同时符合下列情形的除外：

（一）根据食品安全法第一百五十条关于食品安全的规定，足以认定标签、说明书瑕疵不影响食品安全；

（二）根据购买者在购买食品时是否明知瑕疵存在、瑕疵是否会导致普通消费者对食品安全产生误解等事实，足以认定标签、说明书瑕疵不会对消费者造成误导。

第八条 购买者以食品的标签、说明书不符合食品安全标准为由请求生产者或者经营者支付惩罚性赔偿金，食品的标签、说明书虽存在瑕疵但属于下列情形之一的，人民法院不予支持：

（一）文字、符号、数字的字号、字体、字高不规范，或者外文字号、字高大于中文；

（二）出现错别字、多字、漏字、繁体字或者外文翻译不准确，但不会导致消费者对食品安全产生误解；

（三）净含量、规格的标示方式和格式不规范，食品、食品添加剂以及配料使用的俗称或者简称等不规范，营养成分表、配料表顺序、数值、单位标示不规范，或者营养成分表数值修约间隔、“0”界限值、标示单位不规范，但不会导致消费者对食品安全产生误解；

（四）对没有特殊贮存条件要求的食品，未按照规定标示贮存条件；

（五）食品的标签、说明书存在其他瑕疵，但不影响食品安全且不会对消费者造成误导。

第九条 经营明知是不符合食品安全标准的食品或者明知是假药、劣药仍然销售、使用的行为构成欺诈，购买者选择依照食品安全法第一百四十八条第二款、药品管理法第一百四十四条第三款或者消费者权益保护法第五十五条第一款规定起诉请求经营者承担惩罚性赔偿责任的，人民法院应予支持。

购买者依照食品安全法第一百四十八条第二款或者药品管理法第一百四十四条第三款规定起诉请求经营者承担惩罚性赔偿责任，人民法院经审理认为购买者请求不成立但经营者行为构成欺诈，购买者变更为依照消费者权益保护法第五十五条第一款规定请求经营者承担惩罚性赔偿责任的，人民法院应当准许。

第十条 购买者因个人或者家庭生活消费需要购买的药品是假药、劣药，依照药品管理法第一百四十四条第三款规定请求生产者或者经营者支付惩罚性赔偿金的，人民法院依法予以支持。

第十一条 购买者依照药品管理法第一百四十四条第三款规定请求生产者或者经营者支付惩罚性赔偿金，生产者或者经营者抗辩不应适用药品管理法第一百四十四条第三款规定，存在下列情形之一的，人民法院对其抗辩应予支持：

（一）不以营利为目的实施带有自救、互助性质的生产、销售少量药品行为，且未造成他人伤害后果；

（二）根据民间传统配方制售药品，数量不大，且未造成他人伤害后果；

（三）不以营利为目的实施带有自救、互助性质的进口少量境外合法上市药品行为。

对于是否属于民间传统配方难以确定的，可以根据地市级以上药品监督管理部门或者有关部门出具的意见，结合其他证据作出认定。

行政机关作出的处罚决定或者行政机关、药品检验机构提供的检验结论、认定意见等证据足以证明生产、销售或者使用的药品属于假药、劣药的，不适用本条第一款规定。

第十二条 购买者明知所购买食品不符合食品安全标准，依照食品安全法第一百四十八条第二款规定请求生产者或者经营者支付价款十倍的惩罚性赔偿金的，人民法院应当在合理生活消费需要范围内依法支持购买者诉讼请求。

人民法院可以综合保质期、普通消费者通常消费习惯等因素认定购买者合理生活消费需要的食品数量。

生产者或者经营者主张购买者明知所购买食品不符合食品安全标准仍然购买索赔的，应当提供证据证明其主张。

第十三条 购买者明知食品不符合食品安全标准，在短时间内多次购买，并依照食品安全法第一百四十八条第二款规定起诉请求同一生产者或者经营者按每次购买金额分别计算惩罚性赔偿金的，人民法院应当根据购买者多次购买相同食品的总数，在合理生活消费需要范围内依法支持其诉讼请求。

第十四条 购买者明知所购买食品不符合食品安全标准，在短时间内多次购买，并多次依照食品安全法第一百四十八条第二款规定就同一不符合食品安全标准的食品起诉请求同一生产者或者经营者支付惩罚性赔偿金的，人民法院应当在合理生活消费需要范围内依法支持其诉讼请求。

人民法院可以综合保质期、普通消费者通常消费习惯、购买者的购买频次等因素认定购买者每次起诉的食品数量是否超出合理生活消费需要。

第十五条 人民法院在审理食品药品纠纷案件过程中，发现购买者恶意制造生产者或者经营者违法生产经营食品、药品的假象，以投诉、起诉等方式相要挟，向生产者或者经营者索取赔偿金，涉嫌敲诈勒索的，应当及时将有关违法犯罪线索、材料移送公安机关。

第十六条 购买者恶意制造生产者或者经营者违法生产经营食品、药品的假象，起诉请求生产者或者经营者承担赔偿责任的，人民法院应当驳回购买者诉讼请求；构成虚假诉讼的，人民法院应当依照民事诉讼法相关规定，根据情节轻重对其予以罚款、拘留。

购买者行为侵害生产者或者经营者的名誉权等权利，生产者或者经营者请求购买者承担损害赔偿等民事责任的，人民法院应予支持。

第十七条 人民法院在审理食品药品纠纷案件过程中，发现当事人的行为涉嫌生产、销售有毒、有害食品及假药、劣药，虚假诉讼等违法犯罪的，应当及时将有关违法犯罪线索、材料移送有关行政机关和公安机关。

第十八条 人民法院在审理食品药品纠纷案件过程中，发现违法生产、销售、使用食品、药品行为的，可以向有关行政机关、生产者或者经营者发出司法建议。

第十九条 本解释自2024年8月22日起施行。

本解释施行后尚未终审的民事案件，适用本解释；本解释施行前已经终审，当事人申请再审或者按照审判监督程序决定再审的民事案件，不适用本解释。

声明：本文仅供交流学习，版权归原作者所有，若来源标注错误或侵犯到您的权益，烦请告知删除。

经济纠纷视频说法更多

还不上信用卡怎么办

师瑞律师

10-23 859次

隐瞒妻子打赏主播的钱能全部要回吗?

丈夫偷偷打赏给主播,妻子能要回一半吗？显然这种说法是不对的，夫妻财产一人一半只体现在离婚分割财产时，

师瑞律师

10-19 777次

哪些情况可以拒交或少交物业费？

哪些情况可以拒交或少交物业费呢？一、还未交房物业费由开发商缴纳；二、物业公司没有经过业主的同意提高收

师瑞律师

10-17 640次

经济纠纷图文说法更多

因基础法律关系清算达成的借贷关系，可以民间借贷纠纷诉讼

对于借款、货物交易，通常存在相同当事人之间由多笔款项形成的纠纷，又不属于同一合同项下款项，甚至没有签

王家旭律师

12-04 1027次

法定代表人以个人名义借款后，借款用于公司经营的诉讼

法人的法定代表人以个人名义与出借人订立民间借贷合同，所借款项用于单位生产经营。此种情况，司法解释明确

王家旭律师

12-01 919次

“定金”与“订金”仅一字之差，有何区别

“定金”是合同的双方当事人为确保合同的订立、生效或履行等而自愿约定的一种担保形式，是违约责任承担的方

王家旭律师

11-28 583次

经济纠纷律师问答更多

父母有债务，登记在未成年子女名下房屋能否排除强执？

房屋虽登记在未成年子女名下，但法院可在综合分析房屋的购买时间、产权登记时间、购房款支付和购买后的使用情况等因素的基础上，认定房屋应为其父母的家庭共有财产，未成年子女不享有该房屋的所有权。并据此认定该子女对案涉房屋的权利不足以排除强制执行。

10-23 180次

民间借贷合同未约定利息或者利息约定不明，出借人主张利息的，如何处理？

民法典合同编第十二章借款合同规范的是所有类型的合同，既包括自然人、法人和非法人组织之间进行资金融通而成立的借款合同即民间借贷合同，也包括依法设立的从事贷款业务的金融机构向借款人发放贷款而成立的借款合同即金融借款合同。因此，依据民法典第六百八十条第二款的规定，只要是借款合同没有约定利息，那么无论该借款合同是金融借款合同还是民间借贷合同，也不管借款合同是自然人之间的还是非自然人之间的，一律视为不支付利息。此外，民法典第六百八十条第三款前半句即“借款合同对支付利息约定不明确，当事人不能达成补充协议的，按照当地或者当事人的交易方式、交易习惯、市场利率等因素确定利息”，也适用于除了自然人之间的借款合同之外的所有类型的借款合同。

10-22 203次

签了同意担保承诺书，就一定要承担保证责任吗？

《民法典》第三百八十八条规定了设立担保物权应当订立担保合同，包括抵押合同、质押合同等。担保承诺函作为担保合同的一种形式，自然受到这些法条的规范，具有法律效力。那是否就表明，只要签了《同意担保承诺书》或者《同意担保承诺函》，因其具有法律属性，就一定要承担保证责任呢？其实，并不尽然。担保承诺函中，保证人承诺在债务人不履行到期债务时承担担保责任，担保责任的范围、期限等应在担保合同中明确约定。司法实践中，常会出现未约定或未明确约定这些事项的情况，这就需要依据相关法律规定进行补充解释。在未约定保证期间的情况下，不论是一般保证还是连带责任保证，保证期间均为主债务履行期限届满之日起6个月，债权人未在保证期间请求保证人承担保证责任的，保证人不再承担保证责任。

10-16 210次

说法作者

律赢时代律师专职律师

北京裕仁律师事务所

点击咨询律师

热门视频说法

广东医科大学玻璃瓶伤人事件法律分析

王诗元律师 08-22

河北邯郸三名中学生杀害初中生事件，法律会怎么判？

邵飞律师 03-18

如果发现小区内有人遛狗不拴绳如何维权？

师瑞律师 10-24

刑事案件到了检察院，律师能做什么

崔博律师 07-18

代位继承只能继承被代位人可继承的份额吗

林福明律师 07-17

热门图文说法

“董监高”催缴出资义务的法律责任

饶婷婷律师 07-12

企业破产后被遗忘的打工人，律师接受委托帮助员工确认了职工债权

沈光辉律师 09-02

结婚前欠的钱属于夫妻共同债务吗

律赢时代律师 12-13

从公司之间买卖合同纠纷中，看公司股东是否能够为公司尚未发生的债务做担保

邵飞律师 03-11

以诉讼时效抗辩抵赖的债权债务案件，我方终获胜诉判决

沈光辉律师 09-14

基本文件流程错误 SQL 调试

/www/wwwroot/lawly/index.php ( 0.76 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/start.php ( 0.74 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/base.php ( 2.66 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/library/think/Loader.php ( 21.73 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/vendor/composer/autoload_static.php ( 3.04 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/vendor/topthink/think-helper/src/helper.php ( 2.88 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/vendor/topthink/think-captcha/src/helper.php ( 1.59 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/library/think/Route.php ( 61.83 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/library/think/Config.php ( 6.58 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/library/think/Validate.php ( 42.96 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/vendor/topthink/think-migration/src/config.php ( 0.83 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/library/think/Console.php ( 23.98 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/vendor/topthink/think-queue/src/common.php ( 1.19 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/library/think/Error.php ( 3.88 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/convention.php ( 10.66 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/library/think/App.php ( 22.17 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/library/think/Request.php ( 51.43 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/application/config.php ( 12.28 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/application/database.php ( 1.94 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/application/extra/queue.php ( 0.62 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/library/think/Hook.php ( 4.86 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/application/tags.php ( 0.99 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/application/common.php ( 9.77 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/library/think/Env.php ( 1.25 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/helper.php ( 17.87 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/library/think/Lang.php ( 7.49 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/library/think/Log.php ( 6.28 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/lang/zh-cn.php ( 11.94 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/application/route.php ( 11.66 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/application/index/controller/Info.php ( 10.33 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/application/index/controller/Common.php ( 3.15 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/library/think/Controller.php ( 6.29 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/library/traits/controller/Jump.php ( 5.06 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/application/index/model/Base.php ( 2.34 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/library/think/Model.php ( 71.44 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/library/think/Db.php ( 6.85 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/library/think/db/connector/Mysql.php ( 4.02 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/library/think/db/Connection.php ( 31.00 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/library/think/db/Query.php ( 96.72 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/library/think/db/builder/Mysql.php ( 4.66 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/library/think/db/Builder.php ( 32.43 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/application/index/model/Login.php ( 1.52 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/library/think/View.php ( 7.01 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/library/think/view/driver/Think.php ( 5.80 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/library/think/Template.php ( 46.02 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/library/think/template/driver/File.php ( 2.31 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/library/think/Session.php ( 11.22 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/library/think/Debug.php ( 7.37 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/library/think/db/Expression.php ( 1.16 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/extend/Org/Net/IpLocation.php ( 8.86 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/application/index/model/Info.php ( 3.03 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/application/index/model/Lawyer.php ( 3.65 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/application/index/model/Online.php ( 4.52 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/library/think/Cache.php ( 6.34 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/library/think/cache/driver/Redis.php ( 5.37 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/library/think/cache/Driver.php ( 6.21 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/runtime/temp/6d59247d5a377468ff5e3948995332e2.php ( 27.89 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/library/think/Response.php ( 8.61 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/library/think/debug/Html.php ( 4.28 KB )

[ DB ] CONNECT:[ UseTime:0.000314s ] mysql:host=127.0.0.1;dbname=lawly;charset=utf8
[ SQL ] SHOW COLUMNS FROM `think_site` [ RunTime:0.000704s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_site` WHERE `domain` = 'lawly.cn' LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000361s ]
[ SQL ] SHOW COLUMNS FROM `think_base` [ RunTime:0.000566s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=1000 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000218s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=1100 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000197s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=1200 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000223s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=1300 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000221s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=1400 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000225s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=1500 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000193s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=1600 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000236s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=1700 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000245s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=1800 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000244s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=1900 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000210s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=2000 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000219s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=2100 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000225s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=2200 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000183s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=2300 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000226s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=2400 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000195s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=2500 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000309s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=2600 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000194s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=2700 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000377s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=2800 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000231s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=2900 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000235s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=3000 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.007878s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=3100 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000189s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=3200 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000204s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=3300 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000224s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=3400 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000233s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=3500 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000326s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=3600 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000217s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=3700 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000213s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=3800 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000230s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=3900 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.007123s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=4000 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000436s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=4100 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000450s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=4200 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000428s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=1 ) AND ( state=1 ) ORDER BY `sort` LIMIT 0,10 [ RunTime:0.000691s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=2 ) AND ( state=1 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000466s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=3 ) AND ( state=1 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000679s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=4 ) AND ( state=1 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000486s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=6 ) AND ( state=1 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000615s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=5 ) AND ( state=1 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000211s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=7 ) AND ( state=1 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000226s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=9 ) AND ( state=1 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000209s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=10 ) AND ( state=1 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000248s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=14 ) AND ( state=1 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000217s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=1000 and lawyernum>0 ) ORDER BY `lawyernum` DESC,`sort` [ RunTime:0.000221s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=1100 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000208s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=1600 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000227s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=1300 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000219s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=2300 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000225s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=1900 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000235s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=1800 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000234s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=2000 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000233s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=2800 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000228s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=1500 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000220s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=2100 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000221s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=1200 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000219s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=2600 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000226s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=2200 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000217s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=2400 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000229s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=2500 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000232s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=1400 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000244s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=1700 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000753s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=3100 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000233s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=3300 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000227s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=3400 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000238s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=3900 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000219s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=4000 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000221s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=17 and id<>28 ) AND ( state=1 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000235s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=18 ) AND ( state=1 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000213s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=19 ) AND ( state=1 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000222s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=24 ) AND ( state=1 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000232s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=25 ) AND ( state=1 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000233s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=26 ) AND ( state=1 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000213s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( name="美国" ) [ RunTime:0.000219s ]
[ SQL ] SHOW COLUMNS FROM `think_info` [ RunTime:0.000697s ]
[ SQL ] UPDATE `think_info` SET `sort`=`sort`+1 WHERE ( id=924 ) [ RunTime:0.008968s ]
[ SQL ] SHOW COLUMNS FROM `think_lawyer` [ RunTime:0.000705s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE ( id = 0 ) LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000244s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_info` WHERE ( uid=0 and id<>924 and ptype=21 ) AND ( state=1 ) ORDER BY `id` DESC LIMIT 0,5 [ RunTime:0.010978s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_info` WHERE ( ptype=21 ) AND ( state=1 ) ORDER BY `sort` DESC LIMIT 0,5 [ RunTime:0.000325s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 69 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000259s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 121 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000258s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 118 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000234s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 45 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000252s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 2 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000263s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_info` WHERE ( ptype=20 ) AND ( state=1 ) ORDER BY `sort` DESC LIMIT 0,5 [ RunTime:0.024676s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 62 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.001226s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 79 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000387s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 0 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000347s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 121 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000455s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 79 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000271s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_info` WHERE ( ptype=21 and pclass=3 ) AND ( state=1 ) ORDER BY `id` DESC LIMIT 0,3 [ RunTime:0.007489s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 118 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000593s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 118 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000367s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 118 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000337s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_info` WHERE ( ptype=20 and pclass=3 ) AND ( state=1 ) ORDER BY `id` DESC LIMIT 0,3 [ RunTime:0.004292s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 67 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000537s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 67 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000366s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 67 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000367s ]
[ SQL ] SHOW COLUMNS FROM `think_online` [ RunTime:0.000880s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_online` WHERE ( pclass=3 ) ORDER BY `id` DESC LIMIT 0,3 [ RunTime:0.000539s ]
[ SQL ] SHOW COLUMNS FROM `think_user` [ RunTime:0.000695s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_user` WHERE ( id=27 ) LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000298s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_user` WHERE ( id=27 ) LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000289s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 0 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000564s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 0 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000479s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 0 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000341s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 0 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000343s ]
[ SQL ] SHOW COLUMNS FROM `think_lawfirm` [ RunTime:0.000837s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawfirm` WHERE ( id=1 ) LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000280s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( sname="qa" ) AND `pid` = 27 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000299s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE `id` = 3 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000218s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE `id` = 5473 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000218s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE `id` = 0 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000200s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE `id` = 0 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000200s ]
[ SQL ] SHOW COLUMNS FROM `think_order` [ RunTime:0.000539s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_order` WHERE ( orderid="0" ) LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000214s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_user` WHERE ( id=27 ) LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000189s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_user` WHERE ( id=27 ) LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000191s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 0 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000244s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 0 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000228s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 0 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000328s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 0 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000297s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawfirm` WHERE ( id=1 ) LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000263s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( sname="qa" ) AND `pid` = 27 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000266s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE `id` = 3 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000269s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE `id` = 5474 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000286s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE `id` = 0 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000243s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE `id` = 0 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000255s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_order` WHERE ( orderid="0" ) LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000268s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_user` WHERE ( id=27 ) LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000283s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_user` WHERE ( id=27 ) LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000269s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 0 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000308s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 0 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000332s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 0 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000352s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 0 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000341s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawfirm` WHERE ( id=1 ) LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000275s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( sname="qa" ) AND `pid` = 27 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000256s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE `id` = 3 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000261s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE `id` = 5475 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000285s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE `id` = 0 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000269s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE `id` = 0 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000247s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_order` WHERE ( orderid="0" ) LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000275s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( id="24" ) LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000278s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE `id` = 24 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000261s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE `id` = 3 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000259s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE `id` = 0 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000266s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE `id` = 3 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000254s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 118 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000319s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 118 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000348s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 118 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000317s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 118 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000333s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 118 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000329s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 118 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000354s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 118 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000321s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 118 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000312s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 118 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000292s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE `id` = 3 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000285s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 67 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000316s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 67 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000327s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 67 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000337s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 67 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.001157s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 67 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000241s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 67 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000219s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 67 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000265s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 67 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000259s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 67 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000272s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE `id` = 3 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000218s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE `sname` = '4' AND `pid` = 22 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000215s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawfirm` WHERE ( id=1 ) LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000224s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 69 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000238s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 69 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000268s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 121 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000238s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 121 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000255s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 118 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000254s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 118 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000259s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 45 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000268s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 45 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000271s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 2 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000264s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 2 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000235s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 62 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000236s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 62 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000271s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 79 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000269s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 79 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000271s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 0 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000274s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 0 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000260s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 121 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000248s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 121 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000258s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 79 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000258s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 79 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000270s ]

“知假买假、假一罚三、假一罚十”统一判：法释〔2024〕9号 发布

“知假买假、假一罚三、假一罚十”统一判：法释〔2024〕9号发布