自然人承揽安装工程，其雇工受伤是否工伤？-律赢时代

自然人承揽安装工程，其雇工受伤是否工伤？

2024-10-31 劳动纠纷工伤赔偿 168次

天山公司是四川某市“生物科技园”工程的业主，2020年5月12日，公司与王七签订《加工承揽合同》，将工程的玻璃门窗、玻璃栏杆、百叶安装、外墙干挂、一体板安装及阳光雨棚的安装项目发包给王七。

王七雇佣朱九在该项目从事焊工工作。

朱九在作业过程中因墙体内钢网缠住钻头导致手部受伤，经诊断为右手第四掌骨中近端粉碎性骨折。

2022年4月6日，人社局作出工伤认定，对朱九所受事故伤害认定为工伤。依据为人社部《关于执行〈工伤保险条例〉若干问题的意见》第七条规定：“承包单位承包工程以后，将承包业务违法转包、分包给不具备用工主体资格的组织或自然人，该组织或自然人招用的劳动者从事承包业务受伤，由承包单位承担工伤保险责任。”

天山公司不服，申请行政复议。市政府2022年7月21日撤销市人社局作出的工伤决定。理由为：王七作为该承揽业务的承包人自行雇请朱九在案涉项目务工，朱九与天山公司之间不具备直接法律关系，且天山公司系发包案涉安装工程的业主，而非承包该工程的承包人，人社局适用人力资源社会保障部《关于执行〈工伤保险条例〉若干问题的意见》第七条规定作出工伤认定明显不当。故认为人社局作出工伤认定的事实不清，适用法律依据错误，决定撤销市人社局作出的工伤决定。

朱九对该复议决定不服，于2022年7月29日提起诉讼。

一审判决：天山公司是发包方，不是转包、分包方，不适用人社部意见，不能认定工伤

一审法院认为，朱九与天山公司之间不存在劳动关系，因天山公司将案涉项目发包给不具备用工主体资格的自然人王七，故朱九所受伤害能否认定为工伤关键在于能否适用人力资源社会保障部《关于执行〈工伤保险条例〉若干问题的意见》第七条的规定。

该意见规定承包单位承担工伤保险责任的情形为违法转包、分包，不包括违法发包。《最高人民法院关于审理工伤保险行政案件若干问题的规定》第三条第一款第四项、《四川省工伤保险条例》第二十三条规定均未包括违法发包的情形。尽管承包单位将工程转包、分包给不具备用工主体资格的组织或者自然人情形下，承包单位承担工伤保险责任不以存在真实劳动关系为前提，是对劳动者的特殊保护，但这种特殊保护不能随意进行扩大，因为在工程的转包、分包情形下，劳动者至少是在间接为承包单位提供服务，因工受伤害的劳动者是在承包单位的经营活动范围内受到伤害，由承包单位承担工伤保险责任符合工伤的基本逻辑。但建设单位将工程发包给不具备用工主体资格的组织或者自然人的情形下，劳动者是在为工程的承包人提供服务，并不是为建设单位的经营活动提供服务，若认定由建设单位承担工伤保险责任，不具有法理依据，原劳动和社会保障部《关于确立劳动关系有关事项的通知》第四条的规定，仅限于建筑施工、矿山等企业，且是将自身的工程（业务)或经营权进行发包。

本案中，天山公司不属于建设施工、矿山企业，案涉项目的安装工程亦不属于其自身经营范围，故市政府认为本案不适用上述规定，并无不当。

综上，经审判委员会讨论决定，一审判决驳回朱九的诉讼请求。

朱九不服一审判决，提起上诉。

二审判决：天山公司与王七形成合法的工程承揽合同关系，不符合由承包单位承担工伤保险责任的情形

四川省高级人民法院二审认为，天山公司作为“生物科技园”工程的业主，于2020年5月12日与王七签订《加工承揽合同》，约定天山公司将其物业的玻璃门窗、玻璃栏杆、百叶安装、外墙干挂、一体板安装及阳光雨棚的安装项目发包给王七，天山公司与王七双方形成合法的工程承揽合同关系。王七雇佣朱九，双方形成雇佣关系，且本案无相关证据证明天山公司将工程违法发包给王七，天山公司与朱九之间并无直接的法律关系。因此，复议决定认定“王七作为该承揽业务的承包人自行雇请朱九在该案涉项目务工，朱九与天山公司之间不具备直接法律关系，且天山公司系发包案涉安装工程的业主而非承包该工程的承包人”事实清楚。

根据人力资源社会保障部《关于执行〈工伤保险条例〉若干问题的意见》第七条的规定：“承包单位承包工程以后，将承包业务违法转包、分包给不具备用工主体资格的组织或自然人，该组织或自然人招用的劳动者从事承包业务受伤，由承包单位承担工伤保险责任。”本案天山公司作为工程业主，其将装饰工程发包给自然人王七，既不属于该条规定的承包单位，也没有证据证明其属于违法转包或分包，不符合本条规定由承包单位承担工伤保险责任的情形。故市政府以此认为人社局适用人力资源社会保障部《关于执行〈工伤保险条例〉若干问题的意见》第七条规定作出工伤认定明显不当，进而依据《行政复议法》第二十八条第一款第三项的规定作出撤销工伤决定的复议决定适用法律正确。

综上，高院作出二审判决：驳回上诉，维持一审判决。

朱九向最高人民法院申请再审称：本案天山公司将工程发包给无资质的自然人，系违法发包，应当作为承担工伤保险责任的用工单位。故请求撤销一、二审判决，撤销被诉行政复议决定，维持人社局作出的认定工伤决定。

最高法裁定：天山公司与王七之间不构成违法发包关系，朱九在雇佣过程中受伤不能认定为工伤

最高法院认为，本案争议焦点在于天山公司是否应当承担工伤保险责任，核心在于天山公司将涉案工程承揽给案外人王七系属于建设工程违法发包抑或属于普通承揽关系。

原劳动和社会保障部2005年5月25日劳社部发[2005]12号《关于确立劳动关系有关事项的通知》第四条规定：“建筑施工、矿山企业等用人单位将工程（业务）或经营权发包给不具备用工主体资格的组织或自然人，对该组织或自然人招用的劳动者，由具备用工主体资格的发包方承担用工主体责任。”根据该规定，在建筑施工、矿山企业等特殊领域，为了保护劳动者的合法权益，督促相关单位依法发包，对于将业务发包给不具备用工主体资格的组织或者自然人的，由具备用工主体资格的发包方承担用工主体责任，认定工伤。

为了督促建设工程项目依法发包、转包、分包，避免因违法发包、层层转包情况下责任主体没有资质、不明确等问题，充分保障劳动者的工伤权益，人力资源和社会保障部、最高人民法院先后做了进一步规定。《人力资源和社会保障部关于执行〈工伤保险条例〉若干问题的意见》（人社部发〔2013〕34号）第七条规定：“具备用工主体资格的承包单位违反法律、法规规定，将承包业务转包、分包给不具备用工主体资格的组织或者自然人，该组织或者自然人招用的劳动者从事承包业务时因工伤亡的，由该具备用工主体资格的承包单位承担用人单位依法应承担的工伤保险责任。”《最高人民法院关于审理工伤保险行政案件若干问题的规定》第三条第一款规定：“社会保险行政部门认定下列单位为承担工伤保险责任单位的，人民法院应予支持：……（四）用工单位违反法律、法规规定将承包业务转包给不具备用工主体资格的组织或者自然人，该组织或者自然人聘用的职工从事承包业务时因工伤亡的，用工单位为承担工伤保险责任的单位；……”

上述规定是对2005年原劳动部规定的进一步发展，一是将建筑施工、矿山企业等用人单位进一步扩大，不限于上述两类企业；二是将违法发包业务承担用工主体责任进一步发展到违法转包、分包。上述两规定明确用工单位将承包业务违法转包、分包给没有用工主体资格的组织或者自然人的，需要承担用工主体责任，虽然表述上写的是违法转包、分包，没有明确违法发包的用工主体责任，但规定的前提是作为承包业务的用工单位本身具备用工主体资格；对于承包业务的用工单位本身不具备用工主体资格的，也应当依法由具备用工主体资格的发包方承担用工主体责任和工伤保险责任。据此，具备用工主体资格的用人单位是否承担工伤保险责任，核心为其是否违反法律、法规规定将工程违法发包、转包、分包给不具备用工主体资格的组织或者自然人，而此处“违反法律、法规规定”既包括将工程发包、转包、分包给不具备相关资质和经营资格的组织或者自然人，也包括为规避劳动等法律规定将工程进行拆分或者转手等方式给有关组织或者自然人。故一审法院对《关于确立劳动关系有关事项的通知》第四条适用于违法发包，且仅限于建筑施工、矿山企业，《人力资源和社会保障部关于执行〈工伤保险条例〉若干问题的意见》第七条、《最高人民法院关于审理工伤保险行政案件若干问题的规定》第三条第一款仅限于分包、转包的理解，没有充分考虑到相关规定的历史沿革发展和实际情况，不符合上述规定的立法本意。

因此，本案天山公司作为具有用工主体责任的单位，其行为是否属于工程违法发包抑或仅属于民事上的普通承揽关系才是本案的核心问题。

根据《民法典》第七百七十条规定，承揽合同是承揽人按照定作人的要求完成工作，交付工作成果，定作人支付报酬的合同。承揽合同中，法律对合同主体没有限制，定作人和承揽人既可以是自然人，也可以是法人或非法人组织。建设工程合同的标的为建设工程项目，与国家利益及社会公共利益直接相关，作为从事工程建设的承包人需要掌握相关的专业技术。根据《建筑法》第十三条之规定，从事建筑活动的建筑施工企业、勘察单位、设计单位，在取得相应等级的资质后，方可在其资质等级许可的范围内从事建筑活动。因此，法律对建设工程合同的主体提出了更严格的要求，承包人只有具备从事工程建设的相应资质等级，才能承包相应的工程建设，订立相关的建设工程合同，且承包人必须是具有一定资质的法人，自然人个人不具有承包人的资格，不能签订建设工程合同。

本案中，天山公司作为“生物科技园”工程的业主，于2020年5月12日与王七签订《加工承揽合同》，约定天山公司将其物业的玻璃门窗、玻璃栏杆、百叶安装、外墙干挂、一体板安装及阳光雨棚的安装由王七加工承揽。根据原审法院查明的事实，涉案合同约定内容符合承揽合同的特征，不属于建设工程的范畴，二审法院据此认定天山公司与王七双方形成合法的加工承揽合同关系，并无不当。

基于天山公司与王七之间不构成违法发包关系，王七就其承揽的事项雇佣朱九，朱九在此过程中受伤，依法也不应适用《人力资源和社会保障部关于执行〈工伤保险条例〉若干问题的意见》（人社部发〔2013〕34号）第七条关于违法发包、转包由具备用工主体资质的单位承担工伤主体责任的相关规定。故人社局的工伤认定适用法律错误，市政府依法予以纠正并作出被诉行政复议决定，并无不当。一审法院判决说理有所不妥但判决驳回诉讼请求的结果正确，二审法院予以维持，不违反法律规定。

综上，最高法院于2023年11月22日裁定如下：驳回朱九的再审申请。

案号：（2023）最高法行申1473号

声明：本文仅供交流学习，版权归原作者所有，若来源标注错误或侵犯到您的权益，烦请告知删除。

劳动纠纷视频说法更多

03-18 611次

03-12 602次

员工自愿不交社保，用人单位就没有风险了吗？

邵飞律师

03-12 662次

劳动纠纷图文说法更多

单位未依法为职工缴纳社会保险，职工怎么维权？

劳动者比较难以证明劳动关系的存续期间，这时需要先提起申请确认劳动关系存续期间的仲裁，以查明确认劳动关

王家旭律师

12-01 876次

劳动合同到期未续签也有风险

如用人单位产生了未签订书面劳动合同的纠纷，也不是必然要支付二倍工资的。未签订书面劳动合同的二倍工资诉

王家旭律师

12-01 537次

我是谁的人？——员工不清楚自己工作单位如何维护自己合法权益

本案刘某某虽然工作了几十年，但一直不清楚自己的工作单位具体是哪个，以至于自己的权益受到侵害时，也无法

王家旭律师

11-30 805次

劳动纠纷律师问答更多

用人单位发出offer后又反悔，劳动者能否要求赔偿？

缔约过失责任是指在合同订立过程中，一方当事人存在违背诚实信用原则的行为，致使另一方信赖利益受损而应当承担的赔偿责任。如果公司发出offer之后又任意撤销，或额外增加入职条件，属于违背诚信原则的行为，根据《中华人民共和国民法典》第五百条的规定，公司需要承担缔约过失责任。但追究公司的缔约过失责任，不能通过强制公司和求职者履约的方式，求职者可以通过协商或者起诉等方式向公司主张损失赔偿。如果求职者为了入职新公司放弃了之前的工作，在新公司撤销offer后又处于失业状态，新公司通常需要向求职者支付1-3个月的工资。具体赔偿损失的金额需要求职者提供相应的证据。为避免此类纠纷的发生，建议用人单位应结合自身需求合理安排招聘工作，同时要对已经发出的录用通知负责；对于劳动者而言，应妥善保留与企业的沟通记录、入职通知书、录用条件、薪资待遇等相关证据，以备不时之需。

10-16 297次

用人单位在法定最长试用期内延长试用期，违法吗？

根据劳动合同法第十九条第一款、第二款的规定，三年以上固定期限和无固定期限的劳动合同，试用期不得超过六个月，同一用人单位与同一劳动者只能约定一次试用期。劳动合同法第八十三条规定：“用人单位违反本法规定与劳动者约定试用期的，由劳动行政部门责令改正；违法约定的试用期已经履行的，由用人单位以劳动者试用期满月工资为标准，按已经履行的超过法定试用期的期间向劳动者支付赔偿金。”

10-10 425次

用人单位以职工被投诉为由将其辞退合法吗？

尽管因工作态度和服务意识问题受到市民投诉，但该用人单位提交的证据并不足以证明职工的行为已经达到了严重违反用人单位规章制度或劳动纪律的程度。实际上，该机构完全可以采取其他较为轻微的处罚措施，如警告、批评教育等，来对职工进行管理。因此，法院认定该医疗机构解除与职工劳动合同的依据不足，属于违法解除劳动合同的行为，故对其提出的不应支付违法解除劳动合同赔偿金的诉讼请求，法院不予支持。

09-26 418次

说法作者

律赢时代律师专职律师

北京裕仁律师事务所

点击咨询律师

热门视频说法

广东医科大学玻璃瓶伤人事件法律分析

王诗元律师 08-22

河北邯郸三名中学生杀害初中生事件，法律会怎么判？

邵飞律师 03-18

如果发现小区内有人遛狗不拴绳如何维权？

师瑞律师 10-24

刑事案件到了检察院，律师能做什么

崔博律师 07-18

代位继承只能继承被代位人可继承的份额吗

林福明律师 07-17

热门图文说法

“董监高”催缴出资义务的法律责任

饶婷婷律师 07-12

企业破产后被遗忘的打工人，律师接受委托帮助员工确认了职工债权

沈光辉律师 09-02

结婚前欠的钱属于夫妻共同债务吗

律赢时代律师 12-13

以诉讼时效抗辩抵赖的债权债务案件，我方终获胜诉判决

沈光辉律师 09-14

从公司之间买卖合同纠纷中，看公司股东是否能够为公司尚未发生的债务做担保

邵飞律师 03-11

基本文件流程错误 SQL 调试

/www/wwwroot/lawly/index.php ( 0.76 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/start.php ( 0.74 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/base.php ( 2.66 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/library/think/Loader.php ( 21.73 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/vendor/composer/autoload_static.php ( 3.04 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/vendor/topthink/think-helper/src/helper.php ( 2.88 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/vendor/topthink/think-captcha/src/helper.php ( 1.59 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/library/think/Route.php ( 61.83 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/library/think/Config.php ( 6.58 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/library/think/Validate.php ( 42.96 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/vendor/topthink/think-migration/src/config.php ( 0.83 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/library/think/Console.php ( 23.98 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/vendor/topthink/think-queue/src/common.php ( 1.19 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/library/think/Error.php ( 3.88 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/convention.php ( 10.66 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/library/think/App.php ( 22.17 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/library/think/Request.php ( 51.43 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/application/config.php ( 12.28 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/application/database.php ( 1.94 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/application/extra/queue.php ( 0.62 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/library/think/Hook.php ( 4.86 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/application/tags.php ( 0.99 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/application/common.php ( 9.77 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/library/think/Env.php ( 1.25 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/helper.php ( 17.87 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/library/think/Lang.php ( 7.49 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/library/think/Log.php ( 6.28 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/lang/zh-cn.php ( 11.94 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/application/route.php ( 11.66 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/application/index/controller/Info.php ( 10.33 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/application/index/controller/Common.php ( 3.15 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/library/think/Controller.php ( 6.29 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/library/traits/controller/Jump.php ( 5.06 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/application/index/model/Base.php ( 2.34 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/library/think/Model.php ( 71.44 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/library/think/Db.php ( 6.85 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/library/think/db/connector/Mysql.php ( 4.02 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/library/think/db/Connection.php ( 31.00 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/library/think/db/Query.php ( 96.72 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/library/think/db/builder/Mysql.php ( 4.66 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/library/think/db/Builder.php ( 32.43 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/application/index/model/Login.php ( 1.52 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/library/think/View.php ( 7.01 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/library/think/view/driver/Think.php ( 5.80 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/library/think/Template.php ( 46.02 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/library/think/template/driver/File.php ( 2.31 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/library/think/Session.php ( 11.22 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/library/think/Debug.php ( 7.37 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/library/think/db/Expression.php ( 1.16 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/extend/Org/Net/IpLocation.php ( 8.86 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/application/index/model/Info.php ( 3.03 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/application/index/model/Lawyer.php ( 3.65 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/application/index/model/Online.php ( 4.52 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/library/think/Cache.php ( 6.34 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/library/think/cache/driver/Redis.php ( 5.37 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/library/think/cache/Driver.php ( 6.21 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/runtime/temp/6d59247d5a377468ff5e3948995332e2.php ( 27.89 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/library/think/Response.php ( 8.61 KB )
/www/wwwroot/lawly/thinkphp/library/think/debug/Html.php ( 4.28 KB )

[ DB ] CONNECT:[ UseTime:0.000311s ] mysql:host=127.0.0.1;dbname=lawly;charset=utf8
[ SQL ] SHOW COLUMNS FROM `think_site` [ RunTime:0.000555s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_site` WHERE `domain` = 'lawly.cn' LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000272s ]
[ SQL ] SHOW COLUMNS FROM `think_base` [ RunTime:0.000389s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=1000 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000191s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=1100 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000160s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=1200 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000146s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=1300 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000178s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=1400 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000151s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=1500 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000145s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=1600 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000146s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=1700 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000175s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=1800 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000154s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=1900 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000147s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=2000 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000169s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=2100 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000146s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=2200 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000141s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=2300 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000141s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=2400 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000159s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=2500 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000151s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=2600 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000154s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=2700 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000167s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=2800 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000151s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=2900 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000149s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=3000 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000148s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=3100 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000191s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=3200 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000157s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=3300 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000147s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=3400 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000152s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=3500 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000152s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=3600 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000145s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=3700 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000148s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=3800 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000177s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=3900 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000148s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=4000 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000147s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=4100 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000144s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=4200 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000142s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=1 ) AND ( state=1 ) ORDER BY `sort` LIMIT 0,10 [ RunTime:0.000160s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=2 ) AND ( state=1 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000149s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=3 ) AND ( state=1 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000149s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=4 ) AND ( state=1 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000163s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=6 ) AND ( state=1 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000151s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=5 ) AND ( state=1 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000147s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=7 ) AND ( state=1 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000211s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=9 ) AND ( state=1 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.001108s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=10 ) AND ( state=1 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000154s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=14 ) AND ( state=1 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000153s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=1000 and lawyernum>0 ) ORDER BY `lawyernum` DESC,`sort` [ RunTime:0.000165s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=1100 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000162s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=1600 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000154s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=1300 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000156s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=2300 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000175s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=1900 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000160s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=1800 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000152s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=2000 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000183s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=2800 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000162s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=1500 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000152s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=2100 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000151s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=1200 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000163s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=2600 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000156s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=2200 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000150s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=2400 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000148s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=2500 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000158s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=1400 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000155s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=1700 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000162s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=3100 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000175s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=3300 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000155s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=3400 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000147s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=3900 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000151s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=4000 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000156s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=17 and id<>28 ) AND ( state=1 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000156s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=18 ) AND ( state=1 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000149s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=19 ) AND ( state=1 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000146s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=24 ) AND ( state=1 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000149s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=25 ) AND ( state=1 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000145s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( pid=26 ) AND ( state=1 ) ORDER BY `sort` [ RunTime:0.000141s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( name="美国" ) [ RunTime:0.000166s ]
[ SQL ] SHOW COLUMNS FROM `think_info` [ RunTime:0.000575s ]
[ SQL ] UPDATE `think_info` SET `sort`=`sort`+1 WHERE ( id=978 ) [ RunTime:0.002619s ]
[ SQL ] SHOW COLUMNS FROM `think_lawyer` [ RunTime:0.000509s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE ( id = 0 ) LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000201s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_info` WHERE ( uid=0 and id<>978 and ptype=21 ) AND ( state=1 ) ORDER BY `id` DESC LIMIT 0,5 [ RunTime:0.010093s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_info` WHERE ( ptype=21 ) AND ( state=1 ) ORDER BY `sort` DESC LIMIT 0,5 [ RunTime:0.007878s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 69 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000244s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 121 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000221s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 118 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000194s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 45 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000190s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 2 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000187s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_info` WHERE ( ptype=20 ) AND ( state=1 ) ORDER BY `sort` DESC LIMIT 0,5 [ RunTime:0.017377s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 62 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000919s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 79 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000227s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 0 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000192s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 79 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000177s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 121 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000194s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_info` WHERE ( ptype=21 and pclass=4 ) AND ( state=1 ) ORDER BY `id` DESC LIMIT 0,3 [ RunTime:0.001743s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 121 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000206s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 121 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000180s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 121 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000197s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_info` WHERE ( ptype=20 and pclass=4 ) AND ( state=1 ) ORDER BY `id` DESC LIMIT 0,3 [ RunTime:0.002843s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 67 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000216s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 67 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000187s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 67 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000181s ]
[ SQL ] SHOW COLUMNS FROM `think_online` [ RunTime:0.000489s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_online` WHERE ( pclass=4 ) ORDER BY `id` DESC LIMIT 0,3 [ RunTime:0.000333s ]
[ SQL ] SHOW COLUMNS FROM `think_user` [ RunTime:0.000424s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_user` WHERE ( id=27 ) LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000157s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_user` WHERE ( id=27 ) LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000143s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 0 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000180s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 0 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000185s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 0 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000175s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 0 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000176s ]
[ SQL ] SHOW COLUMNS FROM `think_lawfirm` [ RunTime:0.000451s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawfirm` WHERE ( id=1 ) LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000172s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( sname="qa" ) AND `pid` = 27 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000167s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE `id` = 4 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000168s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE `id` = 5482 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000151s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE `id` = 0 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000146s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE `id` = 0 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000142s ]
[ SQL ] SHOW COLUMNS FROM `think_order` [ RunTime:0.000398s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_order` WHERE ( orderid="0" ) LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000233s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_user` WHERE ( id=27 ) LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000202s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_user` WHERE ( id=27 ) LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000224s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 0 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000225s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 0 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000224s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 0 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000249s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 0 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000224s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawfirm` WHERE ( id=1 ) LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000208s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( sname="qa" ) AND `pid` = 27 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000178s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE `id` = 4 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000147s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE `id` = 5480 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000147s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE `id` = 0 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000140s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE `id` = 0 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000161s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_order` WHERE ( orderid="0" ) LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000141s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_user` WHERE ( id=27 ) LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000132s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_user` WHERE ( id=27 ) LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000131s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 0 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000185s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 0 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000179s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 0 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000174s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 0 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000174s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawfirm` WHERE ( id=1 ) LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000174s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( sname="qa" ) AND `pid` = 27 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000159s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE `id` = 4 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000141s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE `id` = 5482 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000151s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE `id` = 0 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000167s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE `id` = 0 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000141s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_order` WHERE ( orderid="0" ) LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000135s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE ( id="24" ) LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000173s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE `id` = 24 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000148s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE `id` = 4 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000144s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE `id` = 5479 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000137s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE `id` = 4 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000142s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 121 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000196s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 121 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000173s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 121 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000165s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 121 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000173s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 121 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000174s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 121 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000165s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 121 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000188s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 121 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000191s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 121 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000167s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE `id` = 4 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000160s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 67 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000170s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 67 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000210s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 67 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000169s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 67 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000169s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 67 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000163s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 67 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000185s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 67 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000185s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 67 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000177s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 67 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000191s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE `id` = 4 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000144s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_base` WHERE `sname` = '4' AND `pid` = 22 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000155s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawfirm` WHERE ( id=1 ) LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000151s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 69 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000180s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 69 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000177s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 121 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000178s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 121 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000211s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 118 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000182s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 118 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000198s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 45 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000181s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 45 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000192s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 2 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000185s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 2 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000182s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 62 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000203s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 62 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000184s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 79 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000180s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 79 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000176s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 0 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000184s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 0 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000175s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 79 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000180s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 79 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000200s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 121 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000181s ]
[ SQL ] SELECT * FROM `think_lawyer` WHERE `id` = 121 LIMIT 1 [ RunTime:0.000177s ]